Please select your state
so that we can show you the most relevant content.
Updated on July 28, 2022
The Biden administration’s failed “Build Back Better” plan called for dusting off a bad idea that, when last proposed in 2019, the Senate rightly rejected: drug price controls.
Neither the Senate’s previous rejection of drug price controls nor the BBB’s recent failure have dissuaded Congress from trying again to pass this radical scheme.
And despite claims that drug price controls are popular, the American people have serious misgivings about the policy when faced with the inevitable trade-offs involved:
In every other part of the economy, prices for goods and services go lower in response to increased competition.
Price controls for prescription drugs, however, would take the opposite approach, resting on the faulty assumption that quality, affordable prescription drugs can be simply mandated into existence by government fiat.
Such policies rarely work the way they’re intended. Drug price controls result in drug shortages, lower research and development spending by pharmaceutical companies, fewer drugs reaching the market, and longer wait times for drugs that do.
How do price controls work — and what affect would they have on our ability to get the medications we need?
In the first year of the pandemic, Canada managed to fully vaccinate fewer than 1 million people, a little over 2.5 percent of its population, meaning our northern neighbor had fallen far behind much of Europe and even South America.
Canada has since managed to catch up, haphazardly. But its vaccination effort has been so disorganized that the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention now cautions Americans against traveling there.
Canada ‘s lackluster vaccination was the predictable result of longstanding policies that put the country at a stark disadvantage for procuring shots. Canada’s price controls are, in part, the culprit, making it difficult for companies to ship the vaccines provided by Operation Warp Speed.
In effect, Canada priced itself out of the market for lifesaving shots.
That raises a question: Why was Canada so heavily reliant on the United States for vaccines? Again, price controls are part of the problem. Drug companies have been leaving Canada for decades because of its harsh regulatory environment.
In fact, there wasn’t a single facility in Canada capable of manufacturing COVID vaccines, so the country had to import all its shots.
To study how Canada’s price caps hollowed out the country’s pharmaceutical industry is to understand why the same policies would result in failure in the United States.
America’s large, resilient, and endlessly innovative pharmaceutical industry deserves credit for producing the drugs, therapeutics, and, of course, vaccines we need to recover from the COVID-19 pandemic.
Unfortunately, the drug price caps called for in the president’s “infrastructure” package would make it more difficult for these companies to bring future such medical marvels to market.
We’ve been here before. This same policy was proposed in 2019 by House lawmakers. The White House Council of Economic Advisers warned against implementing it, finding that:
A 2021 study by University of Chicago economist Tomas Philipson warns that Congress’ latest attempt at drug price controls would essentially stop drug development altogether.
The study estimates that:
In short, price caps on drugs would not only have a disastrous effect on America’s drug companies, but on every American in need of care, too.
Thankfully, there are better alternatives.
Creating additional barriers to medical care, we know, doesn’t work.
A smarter approach would be to give Americans a personal option for prescription drugs that creates a greater supply of available medicines. Lawmakers could do this in a few ways, including:
Americans for Prosperity has launched a six-figure digital ad campaign targeting Arizona and eight congressional districts whose representatives voted for price controls as part of the BBB.
The campaign, the latest installment of AFP’s “Hands Off Our Cures” effort, features a 30 second video highlighting the Biden administration’s lack of preparedness on COVID-19 testing earlier this year and asks why officials who dropped the ball on testing should be entrusted with something as important as the medications millions of people rely on to stay healthy.
Watch and share the video:
A series of display ads warn the eight House members, listed below, of doubling down on their previous vote:
Dean Clancy, AFP’s senior health policy fellow, commented on this campaign in a statement, saying,
“The government’s negligent approach to COVID-19 testing and therapeutics shows that Washington cannot be trusted to control any part of our health care. Giving these same politicians and bureaucrats control over our medicine cabinets is a prescription for disaster that will stifle new medicines and eliminate hope for new cures. Before they vote again to give Washington unprecedented new powers, members of Congress should think long and hard about the harm that price controls will inflict on patients and their families.”
Washington is looking to enact a government takeover of prescription drugs. But you can help by taking action today.
Tell Congress: Say NO to drug rationing.
Receive email alerts to learn how to get involved