Could the U.S. Senate be more of a consensus-building, problem-solving institution? Senators Steve Daines (R-MT) and Jeff Merkley (D-OR) think so.
To reverse the Senate’s descent into polarization and inaction, they propose steadying the path for nominations and legislation, especially bipartisan, committee-approved measures. The mechanisms are amendments to the Senate’s standing rules: 1) set known timelines on the floor, 2) very quickly process uncontroversial legislation, and 3) relatively quickly consider broadly bipartisan authorizing and appropriations legislation. Current drafts have evolved somewhat from the original proposals, and further changes are possible.
These reforms are timely. Updating federal policies to keep up with changes in society has broken down. The laws lag today’s needs, presidents push Congress around, and lawmakers’ talents are under-employed. Centripetal forces of partisanship and polarization often overpower the gravitational pull of the public interest. The Daines-Merkley proposals aim to bring a healthier balance with clearer routes to forging creative solutions to America’s most pressing problems.
Summarizing the Daines-Merkley proposals
Clear timelines: The Senate floor often moves slowly. Daines and Merkley suggest predictable, reasonable times for nominations: more for high-level positions, less for others. They favor making it quick and easy to start debating legislation at simple majorities while keeping the usual 60-vote threshold to conclude debate and move to a final vote. They suggest limiting consideration for any amendment to one hour. Finally, they call for reducing the waiting period after a motion to end debate – a cloture motion – from 30 to 12 hours.
Fewer artificial delays would shift the Senate’s focus toward substantive policy work. True, cloture motions can often run in parallel rather than in sequence, but tracking timelines can distract from substance.
Quick action for overwhelming support: The chair and ranking member of a committee could move to bring one or more committee-approved bills with no floor amendments and one hour of debate, and two-thirds of senators could waive any points of order. This twist on a common House practice would let noncontroversial legislation move along instead of letting a handful of senators hold up consideration indefinitely.
Today, a single senator can place a hold on legislation that has been proposed to advance under the unanimous consent hotline. Strictly speaking, a hold does not kill legislation, but it indicates that a senator would oppose it on the floor for an unknown length of time. In practice, adding this uncertainty to scarce floor time often increases the costs enough to delay legislation with broad – even overwhelming – support short of unanimity.
Bipartisan authorizing legislation: A committee chair and ranking member with the support of additional members including some from each party NOT on the committee could put forward “broadly bipartisan” committee-approved legislation – a majority of each party OR a minimum number from each party – for expedited consideration. The chair and ranking member would give several days’ notice before filing the motion to give senators time to develop and build support for amendments. The motion would allow for at least a specified number of germane amendments, if at least that many are proposed, evenly divided between those offered from senators of each party. Amendments backed by at least several senators of each party could pass with a simple majority, and others would require three-fifths. After six hours of debate, a simple majority could approve the legislation with any adopted amendments.
Bipartisan appropriations: With similar procedures, the Appropriations Committee chair and ranking member could bring committee-approved appropriations bills to the floor. The motion would list at least 20 amendments, if at least that many be proposed, equally divided between those offered from senators of each party. After twelve hours of debate, a simple majority could approve the appropriations bill with any adopted amendments by a simple majority. The Appropriations chair and ranking member could also make a privileged motion to take up a House-passed appropriations bill and replace the contents with up to three Senate-passed bills under the process described here.
Bottom-up complements
These proposals could expand amendment consideration on the floor compared to recent practices. Committee members would continue to have more opportunities to propose amendments during markups than on the floor, but this simply reflects the relative scarcity of each. Still, off-committee senators could have more ways to shape legislation.
Committee microcosms: The Senate is 100 peers, but committee memberships can skew. If, instead, each committee roughly reflects the overall body for ideology, temperament, seniority, geography, and other factors, each committee could incorporate nearly the full range of views in markups. Having trusted colleagues in all negotiations can bring off-committee senators’ views into deliberations while deepening trust that negotiations proceed fairly.
Amendment filtering: The proposals would have committee leaders and motion-joiners pre-select amendments to take up. Alternatively, the motion could set conditions for amendment consideration. For example, the Appropriations chair and ranking members’ motion could say that proposed amendments with at least, say, four cosponsors of each major party will automatically be considered. That approach would shift senators from lobbying committee leaders to building coalitions with other senators, which would strengthen relationships, trust, and intra-Senate loyalty.
Real budget: Advancing appropriations bills routinely is a step in the right direction. Ultimately, however, senators should review and manage revenue policies and the other three-fourths of federal spending as well. Expanding earned success and buy-in to an annual budget act would help Congress allocate resources more efficiently, on time, and democratically. Considering everything together would let Congress meet budget targets and manage trade-offs. This is impossible with today’s partial and broken-up process.
Implications for the U.S. House of Representatives
The House also can struggle to bring up broadly supported legislation. There, the impediment can be the Speaker’s need to preserve majority support for remaining in that position. Rules to let committees share floor agenda-setting could expand avenues for legislation.
The House suspension of the rules process could simply let committee leaders bring legislation without explicit permission.
House Rule 14(4) already provides a framework for committee chairs to take turns bringing reported legislation to the floor, but the motion to adopt the previous question for a “special” rule routinely supplants this option. The Daines-Merkley proposals can help fill in the details so representatives have a clear, workable, rule-of-law process to facilitate committee negotiations with assurances that bipartisan legislation can proceed, perhaps also with bottom-up ways to filter floor amendments.
*****
Congress can do more to serve Americans by solving problems. The Daines-Merkley proposals are a substantial step in the right direction. The Senate should adopt some version of them, the House should consider adapting them, and both should keep seeking systemic solutions to systemic impediments to effective legislating.